Alice and Steve — Season 1

Sophie Goodhart’s Alice and Steve is a sharp, comedic exploration of jealousy and friendship that, while at times uneven, manages to deliver laughs and heartfelt moments. Set against the backdrop of a modern family dynamic, the series dives headfirst into the chaos that ensues when Alice, superbly portrayed by Nicola Walker, finds herself in a battle of wills against her best friend Steve, played with charming absurdity by Jemaine Clement, who is now in a romantic entanglement with Alice’s daughter, Izzy.

From the very first episode, Goodhart’s direction establishes a playful yet poignant tone, oscillating effortlessly between comedic moments and dramatic depth. The camera work is lively; it often drifts from character to character, capturing the subtleties of their interactions. The editing rhythm maintains an engaging pace, particularly in scenes where the tension flares between Alice and Steve, revealing just how fragile their friendship becomes. Walker’s performance is the standout here, embodying a mix of vulnerability and fierce determination that captures the essence of maternal instincts gone awry.

The show’s humor often sits at the intersection of character-driven moments and situational comedy. The dialogue sparkles with wit, especially during conflict-laden exchanges between Alice and Steve, as they both grapple with the shifting allegiances in their lives. However, some episodes feel a bit stretched, where the conflict could have condensed into more impactful moments, perhaps missing the mark on the emotional stakes.

Goodhart’s experience with ensemble casts in Sex Education is evident here, as she skillfully balances multiple character arcs while maintaining a tight focus on Alice’s perspective. Both series feature complex relationships and a dose of humor, but Alice and Steve leans more into the absurdities of adult friendships rather than the teenage trials of Sex Education. This creates a different flavor of comedy—one that’s ripe with adult insecurities and fears, rather than youthful angst.

What works

• Nicola Walker’s performance: A masterclass in conveying emotional depth and comedic timing.
• Clever dialogue: Sharp, witty exchanges that keep the humor flowing.
• Strong premise: A fresh take on friendship and familial relationships in modern life.

Where it stumbles

• Pacing issues: Some episodes feel drawn out, diluting the tension.
• Uneven character development: Supporting characters occasionally fall flat, lacking depth.

The Verdict

Overall, Alice and Steve is a delightful mix of comedy and drama that explores the complexities of friendship and family dynamics, albeit with some uneven pacing. Walker’s captivating performance makes the series worth watching, even if it occasionally loses its narrative thread.